Photobucket
 
Daily journal of a Lycian witch - pagan criticism in general
Musings, rants and insights on whatever crosses my path.
seshen
[info]seshen
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
pagan criticism in general
A continuation of thoughts based on previous post.

What we’ve got here is a subculture within the pagan scene that thinks disagreement is a signpost of automatic intolerance, and if things aren't going exactly the way you want in life that you're being persecuted. Any form of criticism by other pagans equals intolerance, but on the other hand it's perfectly OK to try silencing or blacklisting anyone who dares to point out inconsistencies or disagree with any aspect of another’s practices or beliefs. If someone stands up and says they personally have a problem with such and such, and here's why, that's oppression. Or elitist, or (place "uppity pagan" label here).

For a community that is supposed to pride itself on individuality and breaking away from the "sheeple" mentality, it sure does rear its ugly head a lot. Somehow, any sort of critical thinking that goes into comfort zone territory is perceived as a personal attack, rather than an objective view that might be worth further study. It’s not going against the idea of "pagan unity" to disagree with, or point out a discrepancy in, or downright actively dislike, a person, belief or practice. It seems sometimes that paganism (to use a psychological cliché) enables victimhood. It’s one thing to provide friendship, understanding and support to a wounded person in their recovery. It’s quite another to hinder that recovery by encasing people in a rose-colored bubble of "tolerance and unconditional love," shielding them from any sort of negativity or things that might make them uncomfortable. That’s not healing; that’s crippling.

Tags: , , , , ,

Comments
From: [info]analae Date: October 11th, 2005 04:23 pm (UTC) (Link)
Re: 'bubble of "tolerance and unconditional love," '

My thought is that "Love your neighbour" doesn't necessarily mean *like* your neighbor. I agree with your viewpoint on this subject. To each their own - if we all agree and force others to agree, where is there room for growing and learning?
wandereringray From: [info]wandereringray Date: October 11th, 2005 04:44 pm (UTC) (Link)
*nods* In complete agreement with you.
phoenixalpha From: [info]phoenixalpha Date: October 11th, 2005 05:34 pm (UTC) (Link)
This fits in with something I brood about a lot. There's a major problem in the pagan community with equating politics with religion. "Because you're pagan, you must be for this!" And if you aren't, you're a traitor. It's offputting, especially to those of us (like me), who came at things from a very libertarian viewpoint.

Another thought: If we're worshipping gods who have strong war associations (Kali, the Morrigan, my Inanna), then why the hell are we anti-war? Are the wars from many centuries past more just and 'better' than the wars we're fighting today? Isn't it all the same thing?
woolysw From: [info]woolysw Date: October 11th, 2005 10:55 pm (UTC) (Link)
Actually, a lot of it seems to track with typical fundamentalist belief systems.

No criticism, no original thought, no rational, reasoned thinking, knee-jerk reactions to any opposing opinions - why sometimes can I not tell a lot of difference between fundy Christians and many pagans?

Sigh.
4 ringie-dingies Call me!
Welcome to "Seshen Central"
Seshen - Wiccan, Pagan, Texan
User: [info]seshen
Name: Seshen - Wiccan, Pagan, Texan
Website: Seshen.us
Where the ?#@% Is Everything?
We Don't Need No Stinkin' Theme

This LJ has no particular theme. It is a mixture of what amuses me at the moment, or events that are occurring.

Linkage I Find Enlightening, Interesting, Useful or Amusing
tags